Skip to main content
medieval deskMonday, 22 June 2026

BYZANTINE BUSSY BONANZA: HOW MONK-ON-MONK ACTION ALMOST FIXED THE GREAT SCHISM

Turns out the only thing holier than God is premium, grade-A gossip scrawled in the margins of a perfectly good psalter.

By Cassandra "Cassie" Vexley
Brother Gerald, hard at work on the Book of Kells' lesser-known, far more interesting centerfold.
Brother Gerald, hard at work on the Book of Kells' lesser-known, far more interesting centerfold.
Subscribe to the PhonographApple PodcastsSpotifyMore options

Brother Gerald of Wexford was, by all accounts, a man on the edge. Not in a cool, mysterious way—more in a “if I have to illuminate one more goddamn letter ‘P’ I’m going to shove this quill through my own eyeball” kind of way. The year is, let’s say, 988. The scriptorium at St. Cuthbert’s-in-the-Swamp is cold, the ink is starting to smell suspiciously like week-old piss, and Gerald’s been tasked with copying the Book of Job. Again. Job, that windy bastard, had it coming.

So, on a Tuesday, fueled by watered-down ale and profound spiritual boredom, Gerald started doodling in the margins. It started small. A little caricature of the Emperor Basil II looking constipated on the imperial toilet. Then he drew the Empress consort with a thought bubble saying, “I wonder if Belisarius ever tried wrestling a bear *naked*?” Within a week, this humble marginalia had morphed into a full-blown, multi-chapter saga of courtly intrigue and spectacular fucking that would make the *Decameron* blush. This wasn’t just fic; this was *filth*. The first blockbuster, *Theodora’s Secret Stables*, imagined the 6th-century empress—dead for 400 years, but who’s counting?—had a reverse harem of strapping Goth stable-boys. It was an instant hit. The manuscript was passed under cloaks from Armagh to Aquitaine, each new scribe adding a chapter, a kink, or a wildly inaccurate detail about Byzantine upholstery.

This underground literary movement—or bowel movement, depending on which abbot you asked—hit its peak with *The Eunuch’s Enthroning*, a 72-chapter epic that was less about courtly life and more a surprisingly detailed instruction manual for achieving climax using only a well-oiled sceptre and the power of prayer. Its author, one “Frater Fornicatus,” was rumored to be a Cistercian who’d been on a vow of silence for twenty years, communicating his horny gospel entirely through dick jokes drawn in vellum. The whole glorious, blasphemous enterprise came crashing down when a copy, disguised as a treatise on crop rotation, landed on the desk of Pope John XV—a man whose primary hobby was collecting jewel-encrusted spoons.

But here’s the kicker. The Pope *loved* it. He found it absolutely hilarious. According to the (probably fake) *Annales of Papal Pastimes*, His Holiness’s wheezing laughter shook the Lateran Palace for three straight days. Rather than excommunicating the lot of them, he sent a papal bull demanding sequels. Suddenly, Brother Gerald and his merry band of perverts were the Church’s unofficial propaganda arm, churning out tales of Byzantine debauchery to make the Eastern Empire look like a gaggle of godless, sex-crazed maniacs right before the Great Schism. It didn’t heal the rift, of course—in fact, Patriarch Nicholas II of Constantinople’s formal complaint about being depicted in a torrid affair with a pelican probably sped things up—but it did give us some of the finest pornographic literature of the 10th century. And for that, we must be grateful.

His Holiness reviews the latest diplomatic dispatches from the East. And the fan mail.
His Holiness reviews the latest diplomatic dispatches from the East. And the fan mail.

Does this timeline hold?

+11
readers agreeWhat's this?